CERT-In and Claude Mythos: How AI Can Find Software Flaws
In Brief
The Indian Express reported that CERT-In has begun limited trials of Anthropic’s Claude Mythos to find software vulnerabilities. The trial illustrates how AI can help cyber defenders and why testing sensitive systems requires tight controls.
UPSC Angle
Prelims: Distinguish zero-day vulnerabilities, exploits and patches, and identify CERT-In’s statutory role.
Mains: GS3 - Examine how AI can strengthen cybersecurity while creating risks for sensitive data and critical infrastructure.
Explained
What is CERT-In reportedly testing?
Controlled trial: The Indian Express cited a senior official saying that CERT-In received access to Claude Mythos and was testing it on smaller datasets in controlled environments. The account points to limited vulnerability research. The report did not establish wider operational deployment or identify the precise model version. Mint had earlier reported on CERT-In’s evaluation of other AI models for finding weaknesses, putting the Mythos trials in the context of a broader testing effort.
Project Glasswing: Anthropic launched the initiative to give vetted organisations access to advanced models for defensive security work. Its launch announcement concerned Mythos Preview. Anthropic subsequently described expanded access and other Mythos releases, making it important to distinguish the programme from any specific model version.
What is a zero-day vulnerability?
The weakness: A software vulnerability is a flaw that can compromise a system’s confidentiality, integrity or availability. A zero-day vulnerability is commonly understood as a flaw unknown to the responsible vendor or defenders when discovered or exploited, leaving them with no prior time to prepare a fix.
Exploit and patch: An exploit is a method or piece of code that takes advantage of the flaw. A patch is a software change that fixes it. A report from a model still needs human verification. Finding a weakness, showing that it can be exploited and releasing a repair are three distinct steps.
Where does CERT-In sit in India’s cyber framework?
Incident response: Under Section 70B of the Information Technology Act, 2000, CERT-In is the national agency for cyber incident response. Its functions include gathering incident information, issuing alerts and advisories, and coordinating response. Its 2022 directions require covered organisations to report specified incidents within six hours of noticing them or being informed of them.
Critical systems: The National Critical Information Infrastructure Protection Centre, or NCIIPC, is the national nodal agency under Section 70A for protecting critical information infrastructure. The term covers computer resources whose disruption could have a debilitating impact on national security, the economy, public health or public safety.
Why is vulnerability discovery a dual-use capability?
Defensive gains: AI can review large codebases, prioritise suspicious patterns and suggest tests. A defender can confirm the result in a controlled environment and share it privately with the maintainer for repair.
Misuse potential: Similar capabilities can help attackers locate weak systems. A tool-using model may also follow malicious instructions embedded in material it reads or make an unintended network request if permissions are too broad. Model-generated findings can contain errors and should be independently reproduced.
Why do hosting and data access matter?
Sensitive inputs: Production logs and source code may contain credentials, personal data or details of critical systems. External processing raises questions about what data leave the organisation, who can access them, where they are processed and for how long they are retained.
Containment: Use synthetic or sanitised samples, restrict network access, provide only the permissions needed for the task, log model actions and require human approval before interacting with real systems. For confirmed vulnerabilities, coordinated disclosure gives maintainers time to prepare fixes before technical details spread.
What happens after a model flags a software flaw?
Validation and disclosure: An analyst first reproduces the finding against the affected software version in an authorised test environment. If it is real, the analyst records which versions are affected and what conditions an attacker would need. Under CERT-In’s responsible disclosure policy, CERT-In validates reports and can coordinate privately with the researcher and vendor. The vendor can then develop a fix or workaround, and CERT-In can issue an advisory at an appropriate time.
CVE identifier: Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures gives publicly disclosed vulnerabilities standard identifiers. A CVE ID lets different teams refer to the same flaw across advisories and asset records. A patch is only useful to an organisation once it has identified the affected installations and applied the fix or deployed an effective workaround.
How should India assess whether a controlled trial is useful?
Measure the findings: Test the AI and a conventional scanning workflow against the same set of authorised systems. Compare the number of independently confirmed discoveries, false alerts and analyst hours needed for each finding. Record whether fixes are applied faster. Counting model alerts alone gives little indication of how much risk was reduced.
Prioritise by exposure: A flaw in an internet-facing service or a system that keeps a hospital or power network running may require urgent containment. Teams should assess whether attackers can realistically exploit the flaw, what service could be affected and whether a patch is available. This connects an AI experiment with the operational responsibilities of CERT-In, system owners and sectoral teams.
Way Forward
Test cyber AI on isolated replicas with synthetic or sanitised data.
Require independent confirmation of findings and human authorisation for live actions.
Set enforceable controls on sensitive data access, retention and external processing.
Build domestic evaluation capability and strengthen coordinated disclosure and patching.
UPSC Prelims Facts
| - CERT-In | Information Technology Act, 2000, Section 70B. | Column 3 | Column 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| - NCIIPC | Critical information infrastructure protection under Section 70A. | No value | No value |
| - Vulnerability | Weakness. Exploit | Method that uses the weakness. Patch | Software fix. |
UPSC Previous Year Questions (PYQs)
What are the different elements of cyber security? Keeping in view the challenges in cyber security, examine the extent to which India has successfully developed a comprehensive National Cyber Security Strategy.UPSC Mains GS3, 2022
UPSC Mains Practice Questions
How can India use advanced AI for vulnerability discovery in critical sectors while protecting sensitive data and limiting misuse? Discuss the institutional and technical safeguards required. (250 words)
UPSC Prelims Practice MCQs
- What is the purpose of coordinated vulnerability disclosure?04 Nov 2026
- Which is the most appropriate initial setting for testing whether an AI agent can find weaknesses in a critical system?04 Nov 2026
- Consider the following statements. 1. A vulnerability is a weakness in a system. 2. An exploit is a technique that takes advantage of such a weakness. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?04 Nov 2026
- Under which provision of the Information Technology Act, 2000, does CERT-In serve as the national agency for cyber incident response?04 Nov 2026
- What is a software patch?04 Nov 2026
Sources
The Indian Express - Report on CERT-In’s limited Mythos trials: https://indianexpress.com/article/business/cert-in-claude-mythos-anthropic-project-glasswing-india-cybersecurity-ai-test-10949718/
Mint - CERT-In’s earlier evaluation of other AI models for cyber defence: https://www.livemint.com/news/india-tests-open-source-ai-models-to-gauge-cyber-flaws-as-threats-escalate-anthropic-mythos-certin-11783944848831.html
Anthropic - Project Glasswing launch and defensive scope: https://www.anthropic.com/glasswing
Anthropic - Initial update on Project Glasswing: https://www.anthropic.com/research/glasswing-initial-update
India Code - Information Technology Act, 2000: https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/13116/1/it_act_2000_updated.pdf
CERT-In - Directions and guidance under Section 70B: https://www.cert-in.org.in/s2cMainServlet?pageid=GUIDLNVIEW01
UPSC - Official Mains question paper archive: https://www.upsc.gov.in/examinations/previous-question-papers/archives
CERT-In - Responsible Vulnerability Disclosure and Coordination Policy: https://www.cert-in.org.in/RVDCP.jsp
CERT-In - CVE Numbering Authority and CVE identifiers: https://www.cert-in.org.in/CNA.jsp